Here’s a compact overview of Revenue audits/interventions where CGT is the main risk area.
1. Types/Levels of Revenue interventions
Under the current Compliance Intervention Framework:
Level 1 – Self‑review
- Revenue is not yet intervening.
- You (or your client) review CGT computations and returns yourself.
- You can make an unprompted qualifying disclosure for CGT:
- Correct under‑declarations,
- Pay tax, interest and reduced penalties.
- Best position for penalty mitigation and to avoid publication.
Level 2 – Risk Review / Audit
Revenue is now actively engaged – your chance for a prompted disclosure.
(a) Risk Review
- Focused on a particular risk (e.g. one disposal, one year).
- Often triggered by:
- Third‑party info (solicitors, banks, Land Registry, CRS, etc.),
- REAP / real‑time risk (RTR) flags,
- Obvious mismatches (e.g. large property sale with no CGT return).
- You can still make a prompted qualifying disclosure:
- Reduced penalties versus no disclosure, though not as low as unprompted.
(b) Revenue Audit
- More intrusive; may cover:
- Multiple CGT years,
- Linkages with IT/CT, VAT, CAT, Stamp Duty.
- Auditor will:
- Examine books/records, contracts, bank statements, tax computations,
- Run queries on electronic records,
- Extend to other taxes/periods if new issues appear.
- A prompted qualifying disclosure is still possible at the start of the audit.
Level 3 – Investigation
- Used where Revenue suspect deliberate behaviour (e.g. fraud, serious evasion).
- No qualifying disclosure option.
- Higher penalties and publication risk.
2. Typical CGT risk areas in audits
1. Undeclared disposals
- Property / land (especially rezoned or development land),
- Shares or business sales,
- Assignments of contracts and options.
2. Losses and anti‑avoidance
- Connected‑party disposals and losses:
- Losses may be restricted to gains from the same connected person.
- Arrangements designed to create artificial gains/losses:
- Section 811 and specific anti‑avoidance provisions (e.g. s.546A, 549, 555 TCA 1997).
- Complex products (forwards, CFDs, etc.) used mainly for tax advantage – Revenue can deny loss relief.
3. Retirement relief / participation relief misuse
- Retaining excessive control or failing conditions can lead to denial of relief.
- Revenue look hard at “extraction” cases dressed as CGT but really remuneration or distributions.
4. Valuation issues
- Undervaluation of assets,
- Non‑market consideration between connected parties.
5. Characterisation of receipts
- Is a payment really a capital gain or is it in fact income/remuneration?
- Revenue may re‑characterise if there is no genuine change in ownership or no real commercial bargain.
3. How a CGT‑focused audit typically runs
1. Notification letter
- States whether it is a Risk Review or Audit (Level 2) or Investigation (Level 3).
- Identifies the CGT periods / issues in scope.
- Advises of your right to make a disclosure and to professional representation.
2. Pre‑audit preparation
- Gather:
- Contracts for sale/purchase/assignments,
- Evidence of enhancement expenditure,
- Linked loan and bank documentation,
- Valuations and supporting reports,
- Working papers for CGT computations.
- Re‑check:
- Correct use of losses,
- Correct reliefs (retirement, principal private residence, etc.),
- That all disposals are returned.
3. Audit meeting / queries
- Revenue will:
- Walk through transactions chronologically,
- Test commercial rationale vs tax motivation,
- Seek explanations for structures, timings, valuations.
- They may:
- Extend to more years/taxes,
- Request further documentation.
4. Findings and settlement
- If underpaid CGT: Revenue will raise assessments and seek:
- Tax,
- Statutory interest,
- Penalties (scaled by behaviour: careless vs deliberate, unprompted vs prompted).
- Possible publication on the quarterly defaulters’ list if thresholds are met and no qualifying disclosure.
4. Practical defence / risk‑management points
- Document commercial reasons for any complex or intra‑group CGT transaction.
- For connected‑party disposals, be clear on:
- Market value basis,
- Loss rules and any anti‑avoidance impact.
- Keep full evidence files:
- Valuations, board minutes, legal and tax advice, bank statements.
- Use Level 1 self‑review to clean up known CGT issues before Revenue contact arrives, to preserve unprompted disclosure status.
- If a Revenue letter arrives, get advice quickly so any prompted disclosure can be made within the Code’s timelines.
If you outline a specific CGT transaction (e.g. sale of a rental property, share sale, corporate reorganisation), a tailored list of what Revenue are likely to ask for and how best to present it can be given.
Speak to Professional Tax Advisers
To discover more about Capital Gains Tax in Ireland, please call us on +353 (0)1 272 3858 or complete a Free Online Enquiry.